Reserve for Thanksgiving Now! See our complete menus, here!

Gayle Orth Catering
Gayle Orth Catering
  • Home
  • Wedding Gallery
  • Venues
  • Contact us
  • Event Professionals
  • More Menus to Choose From
  • Client Reviews & Awards
  • Curbside Menu
  • Goc Staff Login
  • More
    • Home
    • Wedding Gallery
    • Venues
    • Contact us
    • Event Professionals
    • More Menus to Choose From
    • Client Reviews & Awards
    • Curbside Menu
    • Goc Staff Login
  • Sign In

  • My Account
  • Signed in as:

  • filler@godaddy.com


  • My Account
  • Sign out

Signed in as:

filler@godaddy.com

  • Home
  • Wedding Gallery
  • Venues
  • Contact us
  • Event Professionals
  • More Menus to Choose From
  • Client Reviews & Awards
  • Curbside Menu
  • Goc Staff Login

Account


  • My Account
  • Sign out


  • Sign In
  • My Account

We Offer Many Customized Menus

Celebrate Thanksgiving with Gratitude, Joy and Love in Your Heart

Thanksgiving Holiday Feast

Brined, Succulent and Moist

Maple and Herb Butter Oven Roasted Whole Turkey

10 lb. Average

(having the entire extended family???…we can easily add!)

*

Gayle’s Addictive Flavorful Scratch Made Stuffing with

Celery, Sweet Onions, Rich Stock and Aromatic Herbs

*

Exquisite Pan Gravy

*

Our Own Housemade Cranberry Sauce

Fresh and Delightful

*

Red Bliss and Yukon Gold Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Infused with Fresh Basil and Tarragon

*

Harvest Green Beans with Our Housemade Wild Mushroom Crème Sauce

Enhanced with Fresh Thyme, Garlic and Grated Parmesan Reggiano

Finished with Crisp Shallots

*

Winter Ruby Red Grapefruit, Navel Oranges and Tangerines

Boasting a Simple Dressing of Fresh Lemon and Lime Juices,

Honey and Ground Cardamom

Finished with Fresh Mint and

Set atop of Bed of Tender Butter Lettuce

*

Freshly In-House Baked Herb Rolls with

Whipped Butter

$79.95 Per Person

Plus Sales Tax

**

Menu Enhancing Add On Options

A Stunning and Bountiful Charcuterie with a Host of Delicious

Smoked Meats, Salamis; Our Own Triple Delight Cheese Balls to Include:

Green Goddess, Pistachio and Goat Cheese;

Pine Nut and Feta with Capers, Oregano and Toasted Fennel;

“Everything” with Cheddar, Pancetta, Shallots and Seeds

Grilled Baby Peppers; Flavored Olives, Roasted Garlic Jam,

Rustic Mustards and Chutneys

Accompanied by Our Own Crisp Tuscany Toasts,

Crunchy Crackers and Whisper Thin Grissini Breadsticks

$17.50 Per Person

*

Whole Spiced Glazed Spiral Cut Ham… So Incredibly GOOD!

$9.50 Per Pound (9 lb. average)

*

Velvety Whipped Sweet Potatoes with

Fresh Thyme and a Touch of Nutmeg

$5.25 Per Person

*

Gayle’s Incredibly Special Creamed Onions with

Pearl and Boiling Onions, Scallions, Parsley,

Marjoram and Lush Heavy Cream

$5.95 Per Person

*

Traditional Sagaponak Corn Pudding with Sweet Onions, Ricotta and

Sharp Cheddar Cheeses, Fresh Basil, Cream and Cornmeal

Absolutely Addictively Delicious

$6.50 Per Person

Desserts

(All Scratch Made and YOU KNOW they’re DELICIOUS)

Grams’ Old Fashioned Pumpkin Pie

$24.50

*

Simple and Satisfying Apple Pie

$24.50

*

Marionberry Tart Boasting a Buttery Crumb Topping

$55.50

*

Pumpkin Cheesecake Featuring a Gingersnap Crust

$65.00

*

     Traditional Pecan Pie

$24.50

               

     

Copyright © 2026 Gayle Orth Catering - All Rights Reserved.

Content Manager: Margaret Garraughty


Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

DeclineAccept